Thursday, April 21, 2022

Standard Times Building Assessment Simplified: Asbestos


In early April City Council approved a budget amendment of $60,233 for the former Standard Times building.  After inquiring I learned the earnest money was actually $47,500 and staff had added money used for a building assessment.  They did so for simplicity.

On 6-3-21 City staff signed a contract engaging Freese and Nichols, an engineering firm, to conduct an assessment of the former Standard Times building.  A 6-11-21 "Requisition Approval City Manager Level" document indicated City Council approval was not needed, nor was a budget amendment.

The proposal arose under an engineering master agreement in place since September 2015.  The city's chronic lack of engineering staff meant much work needed to be outsourced.

 The contract was enacted under a 2019 master contract agreement.

City Council never approved the building assessment.  A portion of the funds were rolled into the recent budget amendment but their actual use was categorized as "earnest money."

Council will need to work in earnest to approve funds for asbestos abatement in the City's newly owned office space.

The assessment had a number of recommendations for the building but the one figure that stood out was the cost of asbestos abatement, over $180,000.  Staff had this information in hand prior to the city closing on the building. 

City Council approved $950,000 for the building purchase.  Did they know an additional $180,000 may be needed for asbestos removal?   

Update 5-23-23:  The city budgeted $14.3 million to upgrade the Standard Times building for Public Works and other departments.  Staff will move from the former First Financial Bank building (City Hall Annex) into the Standard Times space.  At that point the cost to upgrade the former bank building for a police station will be identified.

Thursday, April 14, 2022

City to Consider $262,000 for Municipal Pool Filtration System


City Council will hear a presentation on the need to replace the current Love Municipal Pool filtration system at a cost of $262,045.  The pool was renovated in 2012 and the city chose a Filtrex filtration system in conjunction with the project coordinator.  

The Council background packet states:

The current system is a Filtrex filtration system. It was purchased from a company in New Jersey. It is not a known system to anyone in our area or region, our POC for the Filtrex company from New Jersey has recently passed away. Staff have worked on the current system with no success.

That reads as an odd rationale for spending $262,000.  Filtrex has a website with a contact phone number and the ability to submit an online request.  It has a page with specifications and downloads.  


Filtrex will not be in attendance to identify performance issues with their system.  I wonder how they would react to staff's characterization of their company to City Council?

The replacement filtration system is proposed by Progressive Commercial Aquatics.  Their motto is "We do not just build pools, we build relationships!"

Our experienced professionals will help guide you through all phases of development from planning to opening day.

The proposed contract is through BuyBoard and was not put out for bids by the City's Purchasing Department.  

So who helped the city chose the unknown filtration system vendor a decade ago?  Progressive Commercial Aquatics.  Yes, the company lists the City of San Angelo in its Statement of Qualifications document as the pool's contractor.

The company designed and constructed the Municipal Pool and afterwards regularly sold the city pool chemicals.

The public values the city's municipal pool and getting it operational is a priority.  That said, Council may want more details on Filtrex's failures and how Progressive Commercial Aquatics remained our partner since installation ten years ago.  A true relationship would make things clear to decision makers.

Former Development Corporation board member Larry Teague said in 2013 the City of San Angelo does not do maintenance.  "They wait until it breaks, then they fix it."  The $262,045 was not budgeted so Larry's perspective may apply.  It may not.  We'll know more after City Council meets next week.

Update 4-18-22:  City staff provided detail about filtration system issues to Council's pleasure.  They approved the expenditure in today's meeting.  Assistant City Manager Rick Weise spoke of a consulting company that designed the pool but did not mention the name.

Update 4-24-22:  The architectural firm that designed the pool renovation was Bargmann Hendrie + Archetype Inc. and the pool's building contractor was Mega Contractors.  City documents show no design/construction role for Progressive Commercial Aquatics.  

Update 4-29-22:  The city put out a press release on the delay in opening the Municipal Pool this summer due to the need to replace the filtration system.

Friday, April 08, 2022

Standard Times Building Earnest Money was $47,500, not $60,000


City Council approved a budget amendment related to last year's purchase of the former Standard Times building.  Staff asked Council to approve $135,000 for architectural services but added $60,000 in earnest money, $28,003 for taxes and $15,000 for utilities.  The latter expenditures struck me as odd in that most of them had already been incurred and paid for by the city.  

Earnest money would have been put up at the time the purchase price was struck and netted out in closing.  The Tom Green County Appraisal District showed a $28,002.93 payment from the City of San Angelo for the property on 1-27-22, over two months ago.  

The city incurred utility bills since it closed on 8-19-21.  Council chose not to explore this agenda item and approved it 7-0.

A public information request produced documents on the earnest money, which was $47,500, not the $60,000 requested by staff and approved by Council.  Staff suggested their aim was to simplify the presentation by combining the earnest money and building assessment costs.

Engineering firm Freese and Nichols conducted the assessment of the Standard Times building and invoiced the city $28,167 on 7-31-21.  Adding those items together equals $75,667.

 

City documents show two items netted out of the building price at closing, the $47,500 in earnest money and $23,442.73 for County taxes.  Staff did not mention this when it asked Council for $28,003 for the exact same expense item.  

The documentation as to who approved the payment for the building had been redacted from the information provided.  Council's background packet showed the following staff approvals:

Approvals/Reviews:
Charles Michalewicz   Created/Initiated
Patrick Frerich             Approved
Shane Kelton               Approved
Theresa James             Approved
Jeffrey Tomlinson       Approved
Tina Dierschke           Approved
Julia Antilley              Final Approval
A copy of the check is below.

All four check signers were present when Council approved staff's "labeled for simplicity" request.  Earnest money is clearly different than building assessment money which is not the same as taxes.  Obfuscation, laziness or some combination of the two?

Update 5-23-23:  The city budgeted $14.3 million to upgrade the Standard Times building for Public Works and other departments.  Staff will move from the former First Financial Bank building (City Hall Annex) into the Standard Times space.  At that point the cost to upgrade the former bank building for a police station will be identified.

Thursday, March 31, 2022

City Utility Billing Again Nudges Out SAPD


The City of San Angelo purchased two downtown buildings with the possibility of hosting the Police Department.  The most recent buy involved the former Standard Times building on West Harris.  City Council approved up to $950,000 in April 2021.  GoSanAngelo reported:

San Angelo Mayor Brenda Gunter said the city is exploring options to turn the building into a possible site for a new police station.

"We are excited about the opportunity that purchasing the Standard-Times building presents to the city," Gunter said. "We have known for a long time that our police department has needed a new building."

The City closed on the Standard Times building last summer.  The possible use shifted after purchase according to City Council's background packet.  It states:.

In August 2021, the City of San Angelo purchased the old Standard Times Building located at 34 W. Harris Street. The building was bought with the intention of transitioning it for use primarily by Public Works and Utility Billing. 

The earlier purchase was the former First Financial Bank building on Beauregard.  GoSanAngelo reported:

Originally City officials were pushing to renovate the former bank building into the San Angelo Police Department's new headquarters. However, Police Chief Frank Carter rejected the idea because remodeling the building to meet SAPD needs would be too expensive. Carter also said his priority was getting additional officers and pay raises rather than the building.

Over four years the City's press release revealed which departments would occupy the new space::

The City of San Angelo’s water billing office is moving to the former First Financial Bank building at 301 W. Beauregard Ave. Its first day of operations in its new location will be Monday, Oct. 30. 

The water billing office will occupy the first floor of the newly renamed City Hall Annex. Also on the first floor will be administrators and other employees of the Water Utilities, Operations, Public Works and Engineering Services departments. 

Next week City Council will consider hiring architects to redesign the Standard Times building interior for $135,000 as well as approve funds for property taxes ($28,003), earnest money ($60,000) and utilities ($15,000).   

Tom Green County Appraisal District received a check from the City of San Angelo for $28,002.93 on January 27, 2022.  That was two months ago.  

Earnest money would have been offered prior to closing and netted out of the purchase price on 8-20-2021. 

According to real estate attorneys, earnest money funds are basically a deposit on a property being offered for sale. This money is put into an escrow account where it stays while the details of the sale are finalized. Giving a seller earnest funds means the buyer agrees to purchase the property once negotiations are completed. In return for these funds, the seller agrees not to sell the property to anyone else. When the sale of the property is finalized, the earnest money as well as any earned interest is applied to the purchase price. 

Why would Council need to approve $60,000 in additional funds if the deal was within the original $950,000 approved?  

Given the first two expenses already occurred I assume some portion of the $15,000 in utilities has also been expended.  It's not clear how much the city has already paid utility providers.  It appears staff is asking Council to rubber stamp funds already spent.

City Manager Daniel Valenzuela dealt with the delivery and installation of over $100,000 in Water Utility furniture prior to City Council approval.  It wasn't his faux pas.  Is the furniture sturdy enough to survive two moves?  Hopefully so.

Update 4-2-22:  San Angelo Live reported on the agenda item but raised no questions about the change in intended use or requested funding for items already paid.

Update 4-5-22:  City Council approved all the items under this presentation.  No one spoke or asked about the shift in usage and why Water Utility billing needs to move after relocating to prime downtown office space in 2017.  

Update 6-6-22:  SAPD will go into the City Hall Annex as proposed in 2017.  A City Council Strategic Planning session included a slide addressing this.

Update 5-23-23:  The city budgeted $14.3 million to upgrade the Standard Times building for Public Works and other departments.  Staff will move from the former First Financial Bank building (City Hall Annex) into the Standard Times space.  At that point the cost to upgrade the former bank building for a police station will be identified.

Hunt for City Engineer Continues

Former City Engineer Lance Overstreet is listed in City Council's background packet for their April 5th meeting.  Overstreet is on the committee developing a regional flood plan Council will consider spending another $600,000 in state money on the project.

He stepped down at City Engineer November 2020.  The City has not been successful in finding Overstreet's replacement for a year and five months.  It's been a hard job to fill since the city removed the professional engineer requirement for the Executive Director of Public Works job.  City Manager Daniel Valenzuela removed the requirement for Ricky Dickson and kept that in place for Shane Kelton.

It might be a challenge reporting to and being evaluated by someone lacking your basic skill set.  High turnover in engineering leadership and difficulty in hiring a City Engineer should be of concern to City Council.  

Update 6-7-22:  The City Engineer hunt remains on according to Concho Valley Homepage. 

Update 6-29-22:

Update 8-29-22:  SGR remains on the case to find San Angelo a City Engineering.

Update 1-25-23:  As of 1-1-23 the City promoted Interim City Engineer/Assistant City Engineer to the City Engineer position.  There has been no announcement of this change.

Saturday, March 26, 2022

PAWS "Invested Heavily" after City Dumped Unaltered Cats


The City of San Angelo continues touting their live release achievement for 2021.  Last June City Council heard that Animal Control workers dumped nearly fifty cats, most of them unaltered, into various neighborhoods. 

Animal Services released 48 unaltered cats into city limits.  Bentwood, Fort Concho, Santa Rita, Angelo Heights, Lake View, Southland Hills, The Bluffs, Bellaire, River View Heights and Wall received cats with intact reproductive systems, courtesy of the City of San Angelo.  

The Shelter asked City Council for $5,000 in June 2021 to once again fix community cats prior to release.  Community Cats have been a top four Pets Alive strategy since 2019 for the Animal Shelter.

Concho Valley PAWS said it invested heavily in spay/neuter and return for community cats.  That should warrant a report to City Council given Mayor Gunter wanted follow-up on the success of their $5,000 investment. 

Update 4-29-22:  Concho Valley PAWS will hold a grand opening of the Judith and David Hirschfeld Adoption Center at 11:00 am on Saturday, April 30th.  

Tuesday, March 22, 2022

Gilbert Consulting Gets Contract Renewal for 2022


San Angelo's City Council approved another $60,000 contract with Gilbert Consulting for Municipal Court services.  Judge Allen Gilbert retired in 2019 to much fanfare.  Less publicized was his staying on as a contractor.  The item was generically stated on the Closed agenda and had no information in council's background packet.

A public information request produced a memo to council on the item.  The memo referenced the item as being on the consent agenda, not in closed session.

 This is the first year the Judge's contract was explored in closed session.  

City Council has consistently approved Judge Allen Gilbert's consulting agreement.  How did the deal became "New" in 2022 from the same City Attorney who initiated the item in 2019?   

Update 5-31-22:  City Council discussed Municipal Court revenue in today's strategic planning meeting.  It's down for the last three years and expected to fall again in the upcoming year.  One might expect a consultant to help reverse this trend.  If dollars continue to fall significantly can the city afford to keep Judge Gilbert on the vendor rolls?

Update 2-18-23:  City Council will consider another contract with Gilbert Consulting for $36,000.  Council approved four $60,000 annual contracts since the judge's retirement in 2019.  That's a nice $240,000 post retirement gig.